ANTHROPOLOGY 397G:

The Anthropology Of Environmentalism

Dr. Krista Harper

 

 

 


Class Time: Tu/Th. 9:30-10:45 am

Machmer W-23

Website: http://www-unix.oit.umass.edu/~harper/

Phone: 545-0696

Office Hours: Tu/Th 11 am-12 pm and by appt.

Office: 214 Machmer 

E-mail: kharper@anthro.umass.edu

 

 


 

 

With environmental organizations existing in virtually every nation in the world, environmentalism may be characterized as a truly global social movement.  Activists from different countries work together on issues, refer to international environmental laws and protocols, and exchange information on the internet.  Through these practices, activists participate in an imagined global community of environmentalists.  Nonetheless, the meaning of environmental politics is constructed at the grassroots level, as activists creatively translate environmental issues into novel cultural idioms and political processes.

 

COURSE OBJECTIVES:  This senior seminar offers a survey of scholarship on nature, culture, and environmental activism, an emerging area of anthropological research. The course has three aims: 1) to examine contemporary theories of nature and culture as they relate to environmental struggles, 2) to learn how environmental issues take shape, how environmentalist identities are created, and what activist practices are associated with environmentalism throughout the world, and 3) to explore anthropology’s role in producing ethnographic accounts and building theories about environmentalism and power.

 

 

Specific themes for discussion include the following:


nature/culture distinctions

landscape, property, and power

environmental justice movements

genetically modified organisms (GMOs)

“environmentality” and conservation

the concept of wilderness

globalization and consumption

the Chernobyl nuclear disaster

science and technology in environmental

discourses


 

 

REQUIRED TEXTS:

Milton, Kay

            1995  Environmentalism and Cultural Theory.  New York: Routledge.

Course reader, available at Paradise Copies in downtown Northampton

 

COURSE REQUIREMENTS:

 

Attendance:

Students are required to come to class prepared to critically discuss readings.    This is a small, seminar-style class—your thoughts and experiences are crucial to discussions.  Therefore, attendance is mandatory. More than two unexcused absences may result in a lower grade.  To excuse an absence, please bring a doctor’s note, jury duty notice, or similar documentation to the instructor.

 

Written Exercises:

In this course, we will use many short exercises to develop students’ writing as a critical process—a tool for getting more out of readings. 

 

Once a week (roughly), the instructor will pose a question and students will come to the next class with 1-2 pages prepared.  Written work should be presentable (good grammar and spelling) because we will share it in small group discussions.  It may be typed, word-processed, or neatly handwritten.

 

Exams:

The two exams each consist of identifications and one or two essay questions.  A study guide will be distributed one week before the exams.

 

Paper:

A 5-7 page paper on a topic discussed with the instructor. 

 

Evaluation:

Each student will have his or her own file folder; assignments will be returned in class in these folders.  Grades and absences will be marked in the folder so that students can keep track of how they are doing in the course. 

 

Students will be evaluated as follows:

 

Written Exercises                      30 points

 

Paper                                       30 points

 

Exam #1                                   20 points

 

Exam #2                                   20 points

 

            TOTAL:                                  100 points

           

 


COURSE SCHEDULE AND READINGS:

 

Week One:  Introduction (September 6)

            Film: Fast, Cheap, and Out of Control

 

Week Two: Concepts of Nature and Culture, part 1 (September 11 and 13)

Milton, Chapters 1-2

 

Week Three: Concepts of Nature and Culture, part 2 (September 18 and 20)

Cronon, William

1996          The Trouble with Wilderness, from Uncommon Ground.  (in reader)

Myers, Fred

1989  Burning the Truck and Holding the Country: Pintupi forms of Property and Identity. In We Are Here: Politics of Aboriginal Land Tenure, ed. Edwin Wilmsen.  Berkeley: California. (in reader)

Bishop, Peter

1996     Off road: four-wheel drive and the sense of place.  Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 14:257-271. (in reader)

 

Week Four: Anthropology & Contemporary Political Ecology (September 25 and 27)

Milton, Chapter 5, 6

Greenberg, J. and T. Park 

1994  Political ecology.   Journal of Political Ecology 1(1):1-12.  (in reader)

 
Week Five: Conservation, the State, and “Environmentality” (October 2 and 4)

Milton, Ch. 4

Peluso, Nancy

1993  Coercing conservation: the politics of state resource control.  Global Environmental Change 3(2).  (in reader)

Zerner, Charles

1995     Telling Stories about Biological Diversity.  In Valuing Local Knowledge: Indigenous People and Intellectual Property Rights, eds. Stephen Brush & Doreen Stabinsky.  Washington, D.C.: Island Press. (in reader)

 

Week Six: Studying Environmentalism, Part 1 (October 9 and 11)

Brosius, Peter

1999            Analyses and Interventions: Anthropological Engagements with Environmentalism.  Current Anthropology 40(3):277-309.  (in reader)

 

Week Seven: Studying Environmental Movements, Part 2 (October 16 and 18)

Guha, Ramachandra

1990     The Unquiet Woods: Ecological Change and Peasant Resistance in the Himalaya.  (excerpt in reader)

Shiva, Vandana

1989     Women in the Forest.  In Staying Alive: Women, Ecology. Development.  London: Zed Books. (in reader)

 

Week Eight: EXAM #1, Globalization and Consumption (October 23 and 25)

Hartwick, Elaine

1998     Geographies of Consumption: A Commodity-Chain Approach. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 16(4): 423-438.

 

Week Nine: Globalization and Consumption, cont’d (October 30 and November 1)

Dobson, Andrew, ed.

1991     Selections on “Green Consumerism.” The Green Reader: Essays Toward a Sustainable Society.  San Francisco: Mercury House.  (in reader)

Harper, Krista

1999     Citizens or Consumers?  Environmentalism and the Public Sphere in Postsocialist Hungary.  Radical History Review 74: 96-111.  (in reader)

Pollan, Michael

2001     Desire: Control/Plant: Potato (in reader).

 

Week Ten: Culture, Politics, and GMO Foods (November 6 and 8)

Medical Anthropology Quarterly

2001        Exchange on GMO Foods

Franklin, Sarah

      2001     Sheepwatching.  Anthropology Today.  (in reader).

Stille, Alexander

2001          Slow Food: An Italian Answer to Globalization.  The Nation August 20/27 (in reader).

 

Week Eleven:  Risk and Culture, part 2 (November 13 and 15)

Douglas, Mary and Aaron Wildavsky

1982     Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley: California.  (selections in reader)

Stephens, Sharon

1987     Hard Rain for the Sami.  Cultural Survival Quarterly (in reader)

 

Week Twelve: Risk and Culture, part 2 (November 20)

Wynne, Brian

1989     Sheepfarming After Chernobyl: A Case Study in Communicating Scientific Information.  Environment 31(2).  (in reader)

 

THANKSGIVING BREAK

 

Week Thirteen: The Environmental Justice Movement, Part 1 (November 27 and 29)

Bullard, Robert

1992          Anatomy of Environmental Racism and the Environmental Justice Movement.  In Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the Grassroots, ed. Robert Bullard.  Boston: South End. (in reader)

di Chiro, Giovanna

1996     Nature as Community.  In Uncommon Ground, William Cronon, ed. (in reader)

 

Week Fourteen:  The Environmental Justice Movement, Part  2 (December 4 and 6)

PAPERS DUE

Checker, Melissa

      2001 “Like Nixon Coming to China”: Finding Common Ground in a Multi-Ethnic Coalition for Environmental Justice.  Anthropological Quarterly (in reader).

 

Week Fifteen: Environmental Justice at Home and Abroad (December 11 and 13)

Milton, Chapter 7

Lynch, Barbara Deutsch

1996     Carribean Environmentalism: An Ambiguous Discourse.  In Creating the Countryside: The Politics of Rural and Environmental Discourse, eds. Melanie Dupuis and Peter Vandergeest.  Philadelphia: Temple. (in reader)

EXAM #2

 


 

Week #

Date

Topic

Assignments DUE

Readings Completed

1 Thurs

9/6

Introductions, Fast, Cheap, and Out of Control

 

 

2 Tues

9/11

Concepts of Nature, Part 1: Culture and Environmentalism

 

Milton, Introduction, Ch. 1

2 Thurs

9/13

Concepts of Nature, Part 1: Culture and Ecology

 

Milton, Ch. 2

3 Tues

9/18

Concepts of Nature, Part 2: Wilderness

 

Cronon  (r)

3 Thurs

9/20

Concepts of Nature, Part 2: Place and Property

 

Bishop, Myers (r)

4 Tues

9/25

Anthropology and Contemporary Political Ecology

 

Milton, Ch. 6, Greenberg and Park (r)

4 Thurs

9/27

Anthropology and Contemporary Political Ecology

 

Milton, Ch. 5

5 Tues

10/2

Conservation, the State, and “Environmentality”

 

Milton, Ch. 4

 

5 Thurs

10/4

Conservation, the State, and “Environmentality”

 

Peluso (r)

6 Tues

10/9

Conservation, the State, and “Environmentality”

 

Zerner (r)

6 Thurs

10/11

Studying Environmental Movements, Part 1: Anthro of Environmentalism

 

Brosius (r)

7 Tues

10/16

Studying Environmental Movements, Part 1: Anthro of Environmentalism

 

 

7 Thurs

10/18

Studying Environmental Movements, Part 2: Chipko “Rashomon”

 

Shiva, Guha (r)

8 Tues

10/23

EXAM #1

 

 

8 Thurs

10/25

Globalization and Consumption: Commodity Chains

 

Hartwick (r)

 

9 Tues

10/30

Globalization and Consumption: Consumers or Citizens?

 

Dobson, Harper (r)

9 Thurs

11/1

Culture, Politics, and GMO Foods

 

Pollan (r)

10 Tues

11/6

Culture, Politics, and GMO Foods: Anthropological Analyses

 

Medical Anthropology Quarterly, GMO issue (r)

10 Thurs

11/8

Culture, Politics, and GMO Foods: Cloned Sheep and Mad Cows

 

Franklin, Stille (r)

11 Tues

11/13

Risk and Culture, Part 1: Douglas and Wildavsky

 

Douglas and Wildavsky (r)

11 Thurs

11/15

Risk and Culture, Part 2: “Chernobyl Stories”

 

Stephens (r)

 

12 Tues

11/20

Risk and Culture, Part 2: Learning from Chernobyl

 

Wynne (r)

Week #

Date

Topic

Assignments DUE

Readings Completed

12 Thurs

11/22

THANKSGIVING DAY—no class!

 

 

13 Tues

11/27

The Environmental Justice Movement, Part 1: Race, Class, and Gender

 

 

Bullard, Gottlieb (r)

13 Thurs

11/29

TBA

 

 

14 Tues

12/4

“New World Disorders”: Current Research on Environment and Health from the 2001 American Anthropo-logical Association Meetings in DC.

PAPERS DUE

 

14 Thurs

12/6

The Environmental Justice Movement, Part 2: Coalition-Building

 

Checker (r)

15 Tues

12/11

Environmental Justice at Home and Abroad

 

Milton, Ch. 7, Lynch (r)

15 Thurs

12/13

EXAM #2